
Two dessert teas walk into a teacup
It's mid-November in Louisville. Porch fan off, furnace on. Around here that means we've put the iced tea away and started reaching for something that steams. Two of our dessert black teas get more questions this time of year than anything else: Campfire S'mores and Swiss Hot Chocolate.
They sound alike. Both are black teas. Both taste like something you'd normally eat with a fork or a long stick over a flame. But they're different cups, and picking the wrong one for your night is a small tragedy we'd like to spare you.
So let's settle it. We'll compare flavor, caffeine, sweetness, how each one brews, and when each one works best. By the end you'll know which bag belongs in your cart. And if you can't decide, we'll tell you how to own both.
The quick answer, if you're in a hurry
Grab Campfire S'mores if you want warmth and a little nostalgia. Marshmallow, graham cracker, a whisper of cinnamon and nutmeg. It drinks like a cozy memory. It's also our medium caffeine option, which makes it the friendlier after-dinner cup.
Grab Swiss Hot Chocolate if you want full dessert. Dark chocolate, white chocolate, and vanilla over a bold black tea. It drinks like a mug of cocoa that happens to keep you awake. It's high caffeine, so save it for when you've got evening left to spend.
Both cost the same across the board: Small (12 cups) $11.99, Medium (24 cups) $21.99, Large (50 cups) $34.99, and a Cold Brew Gallon Bag for $11.99. Same shelf, same price. The only real decision is flavor and caffeine.
Campfire S'mores: the nostalgic one
Campfire S'mores is black tea blended with marshmallow pieces, graham cracker pieces, chocolate, cinnamon, and nutmeg. The spice is the quiet thing that sets it apart. Cinnamon and nutmeg give the cup a toasty, slightly baked quality, like the graham cracker just came off a warm rock by the fire.
The chocolate plays a supporting role here, not the lead. You get it, but it sits behind the marshmallow sweetness and the graham warmth. The result is smooth and comforting rather than heavy. If Swiss Hot Chocolate is a chocolate bar, Campfire S'mores is the whole s'more, cracker and gooey middle and all.
Caffeine matters too. Campfire S'mores is our medium caffeine dessert tea, which makes it our go-to for an 8pm cup. You get the ritual and the warmth without lying awake replaying your day.

from our shop
Campfire S'mores
Black Tea, cinnamon, nutmeg, marshmallow pieces, graham cracker pieces, chocolate
Swiss Hot Chocolate: the decadent one
Swiss Hot Chocolate is unapologetic. Bold black tea loaded with dark chocolate bits, white chocolate bits, vanilla, sugar, and chocolate flavor. No spice to distract you. It's chocolate all the way down, with vanilla rounding off the edges so it drinks creamy instead of bitter.
This is the cup for a serious sweet tooth. Dry out of the bag, the aroma alone is an event. One of our customers said it better than we could:
The aroma of this tea, straight out of the bag, is heavenly! The flavor is perfectly balanced and just sweet enough. This is perfect for someone who has a sweet tooth but who is trying to watch their sugar intake.
Because the black tea base is bold, this is our high caffeine blend. Treat it like a dessert coffee. Good for a mid-afternoon chocolate craving, good for a movie night that isn't ending early, bad at bedtime.

from our shop
Swiss Hot Chocolate
Black tea, dark chocolate bits, white chocolate bits, vanilla, sugar sprinkles, and chocolate flavor
Head to head: the real differences
Here's the honest breakdown so you can match the tea to the moment.
- Flavor center: Campfire S'mores leads with marshmallow and graham cracker warmth. Swiss Hot Chocolate leads with dark and white chocolate.
- Spice: Campfire S'mores has cinnamon and nutmeg. Swiss Hot Chocolate has none. Want a little spice? Go S'mores. Want straight chocolate? Go Swiss.
- Sweetness: Both read as dessert, but Swiss Hot Chocolate has added sugar in the blend, so it hits sweeter and richer. Campfire S'mores feels sweet from the marshmallow but drinks a touch lighter.
- Caffeine: Campfire S'mores is medium. Swiss Hot Chocolate is high. That's the biggest practical difference.
- Best time of day: S'mores for evening wind-down. Swiss for afternoon or an early-evening treat.
- With milk: Both love a splash. Swiss Hot Chocolate in particular turns into a genuine faux-cocoa with milk, which is what that review above is talking about.
How to brew each one so it actually tastes good
Dessert teas forgive a lot, but a few numbers keep them from going flat or bitter. Both are flavored black teas, so the base rules are the same. Small tweaks make each one sing.
The baseline for both
- Use 1 level teaspoon per 6 to 8 ounces of water.
- Heat water to 205 to 212 degrees F. A full boil is fine for both.
- Steep 3 to 5 minutes. Three minutes is gentle, five is bold.
Dialing in Campfire S'mores
Steep this one closer to 3 to 4 minutes so the graham cracker and marshmallow stay soft and the spice doesn't turn sharp. It's lovely black, but a small splash of milk pushes it toward that toasted-marshmallow creaminess. No sweetener needed. A little honey plays nicely with the cinnamon if you want it dessert-level.
Dialing in Swiss Hot Chocolate
Go the full 4 to 5 minutes here. The chocolate bits need a minute to melt and release, and the bold base can take the longer steep without getting astringent. Then add a splash of milk or cream. One of our customers chased the full dessert experience and went all in:
Wow! What a treat! If you love a dessert tea, like i do, this is a great chocolate one. I noticed the package said to add a splash of milk. I was aiming for a full dessert tea this evening and added cream and a sprinkle
That's the move. Hot black tea, chocolate bits, a glug of cream, and you've got a cocoa that keeps you awake.
Cold brew in November? Hear us out
We know the weather says steaming mug. But both come as a Cold Brew Gallon Bag for $11.99, and cold brewing isn't only a summer trick. Cold-brewed dessert teas come out smoother and naturally sweeter because the cold water pulls flavor slowly and leaves the bitterness behind.
So if you're hosting over the holidays and want a chocolate iced tea on the table next to the cocoa, drop a cold brew bag in a gallon pitcher, refrigerate overnight (8 to 12 hours), strain, and serve over ice. Swiss Hot Chocolate cold-brewed with a splash of milk is basically chocolate milk for grown-ups. Campfire S'mores cold-brewed tastes like a melted s'mores milkshake without the sugar crash.
For a cozier November version, warm either cold brew gently on the stove instead of microwaving it. You keep that smooth cold-brew character with hot-cup comfort.
When to pick one, and when to pick both
Buying for yourself? Let your evening decide. Sensitive to caffeine or planning to actually sleep? Campfire S'mores. Chocolate is your love language and it's only 4pm? Swiss Hot Chocolate.
Building a dessert tea stash for guests this winter? Get both. They cover different cravings, and having a medium-caffeine option on hand means nobody ends up watching the ceiling at 2am. A Small of each runs you $23.98 for 24 cups of range.
Want to round out a dessert flight? Our Black Cherry brings cocoa and tart fruit, and Hazelnut Vanilla leans nutty and smooth. Pair any of them with a cookie plate and you've got a tea tasting your friends won't stop talking about. Browse the whole lineup at our shop.
Hosting this winter? We bring the tea to you
If dessert tea for a crowd sounds like your kind of gathering, our mobile tea cart does exactly that. We pour hot and iced loose leaf tea at weddings, bridal showers, holiday parties, and events all over Louisville. Picture a self-serve chocolate tea bar at your winter wedding or a S'mores tea station at a December open house. See how it works on our events page, or get in touch and tell us what you're planning.
Frequently asked questions
Is Campfire S'mores tea caffeine free?
No. Ours is a flavored black tea with medium caffeine. Some s'mores teas on the market use an herbal base and are caffeine free, but ours is built on real black tea, which is where that smooth, full body comes from. It's still the lower-caffeine of our two dessert teas, so it's the better late-evening pick.
Does Swiss Hot Chocolate tea actually taste like chocolate?
Yes, clearly. It's black tea loaded with dark chocolate bits, white chocolate bits, vanilla, and sugar. It reads as genuine chocolate, especially after a 4 to 5 minute steep and a splash of milk. Think of it as a cocoa that happens to be caffeinated tea, not a tea that faintly hints at chocolate.
Which has more caffeine, Campfire S'mores or Swiss Hot Chocolate?
Swiss Hot Chocolate. It's our high-caffeine dessert blend, while Campfire S'mores sits at medium. If caffeine is your deciding factor, pick Campfire S'mores for nighttime and save Swiss Hot Chocolate for the afternoon or early evening.
Can you add milk to these teas?
Yes, and we recommend it for both. A splash of milk or cream turns Swiss Hot Chocolate into a rich faux-cocoa and gives Campfire S'mores a toasted-marshmallow creaminess. Steep the tea hot and strong first, then add your milk at the end.
Are these teas good iced or only hot?
Both work well iced, and both come as a Cold Brew Gallon Bag. Cold brewing (8 to 12 hours in the fridge) makes them smoother and naturally sweeter. In November we lean hot, but a chilled chocolate tea is a fun surprise on a holiday table.
thirsty yet?
Sip What We Write About
Every tea on the blog is brewed from the loose leaf we sell. Louisville pickup or shipped to your door.
Shop Loose Leaf TeaRyan Harris
Owner of The Real Mr. Tea, a Louisville loose leaf tea shop and mobile tea cart pouring at markets, weddings, and events across Kentucky. Every tea on this blog is one he blends, brews, and sells himself.
Get to know Mr. Tea


